Cosmetics Comparison: Gel eyeliner by MAC vs. Bobbi Brown

mac-fluidline-gel-eyeliner--large-msg-133779974153 vs. 

I’ve used MAC cosmetics Gel Eyeliners for two years and after reading several good reviews (and seeing nice advertisements at the Duty-Free stores) I decided to venture out and try one by Bobbi Brown.  Both are very good products with amazing reviews (and I LOVE Bobbi Brown’s BB cream) but I was a bit disappointed at how I get small crumbs coming off of my Bobbi Brown Gel Eyeliner.  Has anyone tried these before and had the same experience?  (Please leave a message if you know how to make it “not so crumby”)  I have been getting small dots all over my eyes ever since I switched over to the Bobbi Brown.

For me Gel Eyeliner by MAC (official name is Fluidline) is hands down the BEST gel eyeliner so far 🙂  Please comment if you have any other recommendations as I’m open to trying new products and don’t forget to click like!